🧠 How Much Docstring Is Enough? A Practical Guide for Python Developers

Writing too much documentation is a waste. Writing too little is a risk. So… how much is just right?

In this post, we’ll break down how to write clear, concise, and useful docstrings—and just as importantly, when to use them.

---

🤔 What Is a Docstring, Really?

A docstring is a string literal that sits right below a function, class, or module definition in Python. It tells other developers (and your future self) what the code does — without having to reverse-engineer it.

Python even has built-in support to display docstrings via the help() function.

But here's the catch:

💬 Just because you can document everything, doesn’t mean you should.

---

🎯 Rule of Thumb: Match Docstring Length to Function Complexity

✅ 1. Use a One-Liner for Simple Functions

If your function is dead simple and obvious, keep the docstring to one line:

def is_even(n):
    """Return True if n is even."""
    return n % 2 == 0

No need to mention what n is. Anyone can infer it from the context.

---

✅ 2. Use 2–4 Lines for Moderately Complex Functions

If the function has a side effect (like logging or emitting), or the input/return is a bit more than trivial, write a short multi-line docstring:

def connect_socket(data):
    """
    Handle 'socket_connect' event.

    Logs the data and emits a server confirmation.
    """
    print("Socket connected ::", data)
    emit_agent("socket_response", {"data": "Server Connected"})

You still don’t need to list out the parameter type if it’s obvious or used internally.

---

✅ 3. Use Full Docstrings for Public APIs or Complex Logic

When your function is part of a public API or handles edge cases, external data, exceptions, etc., a full docstring is worth it.

def process_order(order_id, user_data):
    """
    Processes a customer order and returns a receipt.

    Args:
        order_id (int): The unique ID of the order.
        user_data (dict): User details including billing info.

    Returns:
        dict: Receipt with payment confirmation and delivery date.

    Raises:
        ValueError: If order ID is invalid or user data is missing.
    """
    # logic goes here...

Here, you’re helping future developers understand exactly how to use your code — and how not to.

---

⚖️ How to Decide: 3 Simple Questions

Before you write a docstring, ask:

1. Is the function self-explanatory just by reading it?
   → Maybe no docstring is needed.

2. Would someone new to the codebase understand its purpose?
   → Use a short docstring.

3. Could this function be misused or misunderstood?
   → Use a full docstring with examples, exceptions, etc.

---

✍️ Best Practices for Docstrings

Do ✔	Don’t ✖
Use imperative mood (“Return”, “Emit”)	Don’t write “This function returns...”
Start with a summary line	Don’t start with long explanations
Be specific with types when needed	Don’t repeat obvious details
Keep line length readable (≤ 80 chars)	Don’t make it hard to read

---

🧩 Cheat Sheet

Function Type	Docstring Style	Example
add(a, b)	One-liner	"""Return the sum of a and b."""
emit_event(data)	Short	2–4 lines with purpose + side effect
api_call(user, headers)	Full	Structured, with args/returns/exceptions

---

See also: Common Docstring Format in Python

💡 Final Thoughts

Writing good docstrings is like leaving clues for future developers — and for your own future self. The goal isn't to document everything, but to document what matters.

📌 Good code tells how. Good docs tell why.